Is rubber crumb safe?
Rubber crumb from old tyres is in the top layer of most 3G pitches, and every few years a news story asks whether it can make players ill. Here is what the main reviews have found, what has changed in the rules, and what you can do if you still want to cut your exposure.
The short answer
The large official reviews have found a low risk to players. In 2016 the Dutch public health institute RIVM called the risk from playing on rubber-filled pitches virtually negligible, and in 2017 the European Chemicals Agency (ECHA) also judged the risk to be very low while recommending a tighter legal limit on PAHs. US federal research published in 2019 and 2024 found that chemicals in the crumb can reach players but that exposure is likely limited. Since August 2022 the EU has capped eight cancer-linked chemicals in new crumb. Questions remain, mainly about long-term exposure for children and the environment.
What is in rubber crumb
Most 3G pitches use SBR crumb: granules ground from end-of-life car and lorry tyres. Tyres are made to last on the road, not to be played on, so the rubber contains a mix of substances that would not be chosen for a sports surface from scratch. These include:
- PAHs (polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons), from the carbon black and oils used in tyres. Some PAHs can cause cancer at high enough exposure.
- Metals such as zinc, used in making tyres, and small amounts of others.
- Volatile organic compounds, which give a hot 3G pitch its rubbery smell.
The question is not whether these substances are present. They are. The question is how much of them gets into a player's body through skin, breathing and swallowing, and whether that amount matters. For what the crumb is and why it is there, see what the black bits on astroturf are.
What the reviews found
European Chemicals Agency, 2017
The European Commission asked ECHA to look at the risk from recycled rubber infill after concerns about cancer in players were raised in the media. ECHA's 2017 report looked at cancer risk, skin contact, breathing in vapours and swallowing granules. It judged the overall risk to players to be very low. It also concluded, with RIVM, that the legal limit then applying to PAHs in the crumb was too high, and recommended a lower one.
Netherlands
The Dutch public health institute RIVM tested crumb from 100 Dutch pitches and published its findings in December 2016. It said the health risk from playing sport on these pitches was virtually negligible, but that the crumb would fail the much stricter PAH limits for consumer products and toys, and it recommended tighter standards. In 2018 the Netherlands sent ECHA the proposal that became the EU limit below.
United States, 2019 and 2024
Three US federal agencies (the EPA, the CDC with its toxic substances agency, and the Consumer Product Safety Commission) ran a joint research plan. Part 1, in July 2019, measured what the crumb contains. Part 2, in April 2024, measured exposure. Its summary was that chemicals are present and exposure can occur, but it is likely limited. Many of the chemicals released into the air during outdoor play were no different from background levels. Only small fractions of the metals dissolved in fluids that mimic sweat, saliva and stomach juice. In a small pilot, urine tests for PAH breakdown products showed no difference between people playing on synthetic turf and on grass. The agencies stressed that this was not a full risk assessment.
You can read the US findings on the EPA's tire crumb research page.
Rules that now apply
| Rule | What it does | From |
|---|---|---|
| EU Regulation 2021/1199 (REACH, PAHs) | Caps eight PAHs at 20 mg/kg combined in granules and mulches for pitches and playgrounds. Granules already laid can stay. | 10 August 2022 |
| EU Regulation 2023/2055 (microplastics) | Ends the sale of polymer granular infill for synthetic sports surfaces, for environmental reasons rather than player health. | 17 October 2031 |
The 20 mg/kg limit came out of that Dutch proposal, which estimated cancer risk for workers, players and children. The EU regulation notes that no safe dose can be set for these PAHs, so levels should be kept as low as possible. These are EU rules. Great Britain left EU REACH after Brexit, so they do not apply there automatically.
The 2031 microplastics ban is about crumb escaping into soil and water, not about player health. It will steer new pitches towards organic infill or carpets that need no infill at all.
What is still uncertain
The reviews do not say the crumb is harmless. They say the measured exposure is low. Researchers point to gaps:
- Long-term exposure. Few studies follow players who have trained on rubber infill several times a week for many years.
- Children. Small children put their hands in their mouths more, and they weigh less, so the same crumb means a higher dose for them.
- Mixtures. Studies tend to test chemicals one at a time, while players are exposed to many at once.
The cluster of goalkeeper cancers reported in the US media has not been confirmed as caused by the crumb. That does not settle it either way, and the research continues.
If you have a specific health concern, such as a skin condition that flares after playing, see a doctor rather than relying on general reviews.
Simple ways to cut exposure
Basic hygiene is the usual advice. In practice:
- Wash your hands before eating or drinking at the pitch, and do not eat on the playing surface.
- Clean grazes and cuts straight away with running water, and get any granules out. See our guide on turf burn.
- Shower after playing and shake crumb out of boots and kit outdoors.
- Keep small children from playing in or eating the crumb at the edge of the pitch.
- If you would rather avoid tyre rubber, ask the venue what infill it uses. Some newer pitches have EPDM, TPE or organic infill, and grass pitches have none.
Choosing a surface. Grass pitches and indoor courts avoid the question entirely. Our guide to artificial grass vs real grass compares the two for injuries, weather and cost.
ServiceFM Stadium
Adelaide · Artificial pitches
Knocknacarra Community Centre 3G Pitch
Galway · Council 3G
Soccer5s Dandenong
Melbourne · Floodlit 5-a-side
Cities with the most artificial grass pitches in our directory:
FAQ
Does rubber crumb cause cancer?
No review has shown that it does. RIVM in 2016 and ECHA in 2017 judged the risk to players very low, and US federal research found exposure is likely limited. Research on long-term exposure continues.
Are 3G pitches being banned?
No. From 17 October 2031 the EU will stop the sale of plastic granular infill for sports pitches, for pollution reasons. Pitches can switch to other infills or infill-free carpets.
Is rubber crumb safe for children?
The reviews covered children and found low risk, but children are the group researchers most want to study further. Hand washing and keeping crumb away from mouths are sensible.
Do goalkeepers face more risk?
Goalkeepers dive and land on the surface more, so they get more skin contact. A link to illness has not been shown, but cleaning grazes and showering after play is good practice.